VOCA Victims of Chiropractic Abuse
Injured patients want new rules for chiropractors
By Susan Haigh, Associated Press Writer | March 3, 2007
HARTFORD, Conn. - When Brittmarie Harwe woke up with a sore neck and shoulder in 1993, she sought help from a chiropractor recommended by a friend.

But at her second visit, something went terribly wrong.

"When he did the first (adjustment), I felt it, like a rushing noise in my head, dizzy," recalled Harwe. "He looked me in the eye and realized I was in distress ... I was having a stroke, right then and there."

Harwe, 26 at the time, was rushed to the hospital, where she learned that her left vertebral artery had been crushed. In the days and years that followed, Harwe suffered from paralysis, vision loss, weakness and coordination problems, a paralyzed vocal cord and an inability to swallow. Today, she still uses a feeding tube.

Harwe plans to tell state lawmakers Monday that she had no idea stroke was one of the risks of cervical manipulation by a chiropractor. The legislature's Public Health Committee is considering legislation that would require chiropractors to inform patients, both in writing and verbally, of the risks and possible side effects of their treatments.

State chiropractors say the legislation is unnecessary and unfairly punitive. They argue that a state law requiring a patient to give informed consent before a procedure is excessive given the statistically remote risk of injury and death. And they say that the malpractice insurance premiums paid by chiropractors -- markedly smaller than those paid by physicians and other medical personnel -- prove the risks are small.

"I think it's appropriate for the public health community to be concerned about issues of public safety, but I think at best this proposal is a misplaced attempt at patient advocacy and is perhaps prejudicial against the chiropractic profession," said Dr. Matthew N. Pagano, D.C., president of the Connecticut Chiropractic Association.

Sen. Mary Ann Handley, D-Manchester, co-chairman of the Public Health Committee, said she's going into Monday's hearing with an open mind.

"My intention is to sit there and listen to what people have to say," she said.

Lawmakers are being asked to take a close look at chiropractors this session. The insurance committee is debating another bill -- opposed by a state chiropractic association -- that would require Connecticut's insurance department to make public information regarding medical malpractice claims against chiropractors.

The state public health department currently collects data about closed claims regarding physicians, surgeons, hospitals, advanced practice registered nurses and physician assistants.

Both bills were proposed by Sen. Leonard Fasano, R-North Haven, who has a constituent who suffered a stroke after a chiropractic visit. While he agrees many people benefit from visits to chiropractors, Fasano said consumers should have as much information as possible.
"What is so bad about saying here are the potential risks?" Fasano said.

Harwe, now 40 and living in Wethersfield, said if she had such information in 1993, she likely would not have had the chiropractic procedure.

"In this day and age of technology, when it is so easy to get the information out to people, just give it to them and let the person make their own decision," she said.

Pagano said he believes both bills unfairly single out chiropractors. He said no other medical professionals in Connecticut must obtain informed consent from patients.

"If the state hasn't deemed it necessary to have informed consent mandated by all professions, why are they contemplating singling out one profession?" said Pagano, who has a chiropractic practice in Winsted and provides patients with a consent form outlining potential risks.

Pagano said the bills are especially troubling because the risks from adjustments are so low. The American Chiropractic Association says the risk of death or major neurological complications from cervical manipulation are one in 4 million -- the same as flying 425 miles on a commercial airline.

He pointed out that the annual malpractice insurance premium paid by a chiropractor in Connecticut is about $2,000 a year, compared with about $120,000 a year for obstetricians and anesthesiologists.

"I think malpractice rates are determined by a profession's claim history," Pagano said. "If a profession has a drastically lower number of claims, that's going to be reflected in the malpractice premiums."

According to the Connecticut Board of Chiropractic Examiners, which disciplines chiropractors, the state public health department received 57 complaints about chiropractors between Jan. 1, 2002, and Dec. 31, 2006. That's 1 percent of the 4,941 complaints the department received for all licensed medical professionals. Of the 57 complaints, the board issued 15 disciplinary orders.

Janet Levy of Woodbridge, Fasano's constituent, formed the group Victims of Chiropractic Abuse last June. Five years ago, she woke up with a stiff shoulder ache and went to a chiropractor recommended by a friend.

She immediately got a headache, but the chiropractor said it was only a reaction to the treatment. Days later, she went to the hospital and learned she had had a mini-stroke caused by a torn artery and needed emergency brain surgery.

At the time, she was 48 and ran five miles a day. After the surgery, she was told she wouldn't walk again. But Levy persevered and went through two years of physical and occupational therapy, seven hours a day. Today she can walk, but still has balance problems and other neurological defects.
Levy said she could saved herself from those two years of suffering if she had know about the risks she faced.

"You think it's safe. You think it's natural," she said. "Those two words just throw you off. What do you have to lose?"
Connecticut News
March 8, 2011
Three Members of Chiropractic Board Violated Law
June 10, 2010
Connecticut chiropractors sued over neck manipulations
April 6, 2010
No harm in warning about risk
March 19, 2010
Board rejects warning on chiropractic risks
March 18, 2010
On Stroke Risks, Chiropractors Manipulate Us
March 17, 2010
Chiropractors Prevail in Battle Over Informed Consent
February 11, 2010
Chiropractic Conflict Continues in Connecticut
February 10, 2010
Patients Need To Know Chiropractic Risks
January 6, 2010
Editorial Cartoon
January 6, 2010
Advocates seeking state law requiring a warning prior to neck manipulation
January 5, 2010
Chiropractors' Argument Falls On Deaf Ears
January 5, 2010
Battle brews over safety of neck manipulation
January 5, 2010
Chiropractic Stroke Risk
January 4, 2010
Stroke risks prompt hearing
January 2, 2010
Woodbridge woman fights for warning label
December 29, 2009
Chiropractic Patients Should Know Risks
November 24, 2009
Young Mom Dies After a Chiropractic Adjustment
June 18, 2009
VOCA awards Preston Long, Chiropractor of the Year
March 3, 2008
Woman Pushes For Chiropractor Registry
November 2007
Stroke Victim Spreads The Word About Dangers of Chiropractic Neck Treatment
May 16, 2007
Chiropractic and Stroke Issues on the Rise
May 4, 2007
Chiropractor Malpractice Settlements To Be Public
May 2, 2007
A Collection of Briefs from the State Capitol
April 30, 2007 (MP3 File)
WTIC NewsTalk 1080
March 14, 2007
Tougher laws for chiropractors
March 13, 2007
A collection of news items from the Capitol
March 3, 2007
Injured patients want new rules for chiropractors
May 2, 1996
Proposed Law Would Affect Chiropractors